Nutter Butter Peanut Butter Cheesecake

The smell of peanut butter always takes me straight back to Saturday mornings in a sun-filled kitchen. I used to think cheesecake was too fancy, something you ordered at a restaurant, not something you baked in your own oven. Then a friend handed me a sleeve of Nutter Butters and said, try this as a crust. That single suggestion unlocked a dessert I've made more times than I can count, each one a little smoother, a little more confident than the last.

I made this for a birthday once, and the birthday girl took one bite and went silent for a moment. Then she smiled and said it tasted exactly like the cookies her grandmother used to keep in a tin by the stove. I hadn't expected that kind of reaction, but it reminded me how certain flavors carry memories we didn't even know we were holding onto. That night, we ate three slices each and no one apologized.

Ingredients

• Nutter Butter cookies: These form the base and bring that unmistakable peanut butter cookie flavor; crush them fine but leave a few small chunks for texture.
• Unsalted butter: Melted butter binds the crust together and adds richness without making it greasy.
• Cream cheese: The heart of any cheesecake; make sure it's fully softened or you'll end up with lumps no amount of mixing can fix.
• Granulated sugar: Sweetens the filling just enough to let the peanut butter shine through without overpowering it.
• Vanilla extract: A little goes a long way in rounding out the flavor and making everything taste more cohesive.
• Eggs: They give structure and that signature dense, creamy texture; add them gently and don't overbeat.
• Creamy peanut butter: Use the smooth kind, not natural, because it blends better and doesn't separate during baking.
• Heavy whipping cream: Whipped fresh, it becomes a cloud of sweetness that sits on top like a soft pillow.
• Powdered sugar: Sweetens and stabilizes the whipped cream so it holds its shape for hours.
• Chopped peanuts: Optional, but they add a salty crunch that contrasts beautifully with the creamy filling.

Instructions

Prep the Pan:

Preheat your oven to 325°F and grease a 9-inch springform pan, then line the bottom with parchment paper. This little step saves you from heartbreak when it's time to release the cheesecake.

Make the Crust:

Crush the Nutter Butters until they look like coarse sand, then stir in melted butter until everything clumps together. Press it firmly into the bottom of the pan using the back of a measuring cup, then bake for 10 minutes and let it cool.

Beat the Base:

In a large bowl, beat the softened cream cheese and sugar together until it's completely smooth and fluffy, about 2 to 3 minutes. Scrape down the sides so nothing gets left behind.

Add Peanut Butter and Vanilla:

Mix in the vanilla and peanut butter until they disappear into the cream cheese. The color will shift to a pale tan, and the smell will make you want to eat it with a spoon.

Fold in the Eggs:

Add eggs one at a time on low speed, mixing just until each one is incorporated. Overmixing here introduces air bubbles that can cause cracks later.

Pour and Smooth:

Pour the filling over the cooled crust and use a spatula to smooth the top into an even layer. Tap the pan gently on the counter to release any trapped air.

Bake Low and Slow:

Bake for 50 to 60 minutes until the edges are set but the center still jiggles slightly when you shake the pan. It will firm up as it cools, so don't wait for it to look completely solid.

Cool in the Oven:

Turn off the heat, crack the oven door, and let the cheesecake sit inside for an hour. This gradual cooldown is the secret to avoiding those heartbreaking cracks across the top.

Chill Completely:

Move the cheesecake to the fridge and let it chill for at least 4 hours, or overnight if you can wait. The flavors deepen and the texture becomes impossibly creamy.

Whip the Topping:

Before serving, whip the heavy cream with powdered sugar until stiff peaks form. Spread it over the chilled cheesecake in soft swoops or pipe it on for a fancier look.

Garnish and Serve:

Sprinkle chopped peanuts over the top and tuck a few whole Nutter Butters along the edge. Slice with a warm, clean knife for perfect portions.

Save to Pinterest

There's a moment right before you serve this cheesecake when everyone gathers around the table and someone inevitably asks if it's store-bought. That's when you get to smile and say you made it yourself, and the room fills with the kind of warmth that only homemade dessert can bring. It's not just about the taste, it's about the care baked into every layer.

How to Avoid Cracks

Cracks happen when the cheesecake cools too quickly or gets overbaked, so treat it gently. Let it come to room temperature before chilling, and never open the oven door during baking. If you want to be extra cautious, bake it in a water bath by wrapping the springform pan in foil and setting it in a larger pan filled with hot water. The steam keeps everything moist and even.

Make-Ahead Magic

This cheesecake actually improves after a night in the fridge, so making it a day ahead isn't just convenient, it's ideal. The flavors meld together, the texture firms up, and you get to skip the last-minute panic. Just wait to add the whipped cream and garnish until right before serving so everything looks fresh and fluffy.

Serving Suggestions

This cheesecake is rich enough to stand on its own, but a drizzle of warm chocolate or salted caramel sauce takes it over the top. You can also serve it with fresh strawberries or a handful of raspberries for a tart contrast to all that creamy sweetness.

• Use a hot knife wiped clean between slices for picture-perfect edges.
• Store leftovers covered in the fridge for up to five days, though it rarely lasts that long.
• For a fun twist, crumble extra Nutter Butters into the whipped cream topping.

Save to Pinterest

Every time I make this cheesecake, I'm reminded that some of the best recipes aren't complicated, they're just made with ingredients that make you happy. This one does exactly that, one creamy, peanut buttery slice at a time.

Recipe Q&A

→ How long should I chill the cheesecake before serving?

Refrigerate the cheesecake for at least 4 hours, though overnight chilling is recommended for the best texture and flavor. This allows the filling to set completely and develop a firmer consistency.

→ Can I make this cheesecake in advance?

Absolutely. Making it a day ahead actually improves the flavor as the ingredients meld together. Keep it refrigerated and add the whipped cream topping just before serving for the freshest presentation.

→ Why did my cheesecake crack on top?

Cracking often occurs from over-mixing the batter or cooling too quickly. To prevent this, avoid over-beating after adding eggs, and let the cheesecake cool gradually in the oven with the door cracked open. Using a water bath can also help maintain moisture.

→ Can I use natural peanut butter instead of creamy?

Creamy commercial peanut butter works best as it provides consistent texture. Natural peanut butter with oil separation may affect the cheesecake's consistency and structure. If using natural, ensure it's thoroughly stirred and well-incorporated.

→ What other toppings work well with this dessert?

Beyond whipped cream and peanuts, try drizzling with warm chocolate sauce, caramel, or melted peanut butter. Crushed additional Nutter Butter cookies, chocolate shavings, or a dollop of peanut butter frosting also make excellent additions.

→ How should I store leftovers?

Store any remaining slices in an airtight container in the refrigerator for up to 5 days. The whipped cream topping may soften slightly over time, so add fresh garnish when serving leftovers for the best presentation.